SDWTF: The Heavy Guilt – “Mixed Messages”
Artist: The Heavy Guilt
Song: Mixed Messages
I have often been fascinated with what is an apparent trend in independant music these days. The big band. Now I’m not talking about a big band like the kind that Cab Calloway or Duke Ellington would have had back in the day. I’m talking about a big band in a far less necessary sense. Think Parliament, only not really in the same ballpark. Not even close. I’m talking about a big band in the sense that the size of the band is completely unecessary. Bands like The Arcade Fire, and Edward Sharpe and the Magnetic Zeros. Bands that look like at some point on the road to “success” they decided they had a few extra frioends that werent really too talented, but that could be in the band too. Like D’arcy from the Smashing Pumpkins. Well, it’s ok if she can’t play. we will just stick an instrument in her hand and teach her some very simple things and nobody will know the difference. Afterall, she is a girl, and what could be cooler than that in my band?! I know the rebuttal here too. I mean who, other than the songwriter, can really say who is or is not necessary to the performance of a piece. I also am acutely aware of the style vs substance debate, in which one could argue that these employee bloated outfits are that way because it is an intrinsic componenet to the style that the band is going for. which is fine. but it all seems like a distraction to me. The more people there are doing things that the majority of the audience probably doesnt think they could ever comprehend, the more likely I am to think this band is full of shit. It is like a musical red herring of sorts. Maybe if I am so overwhelmed by stage presence, I will be oblivious to how little is actually going on musically.
That is the first thing I noticed while discovering the video for “Mixed Messages” by the band “The Heavy Guilt”. You have at least 6 guys on stage. Which at first, is fine. To be fair, this is not as big of a red flag to me as it is for other bands like the aforementioned. Especially considering there are only 6 guys on stage here as opposed to 9 or more. However it is still an example of the kind of musical misdirection I am talking about. You have what is essentially a very straightforward three or four chord pop song. But then you have these other guys prettying it up essentially. Take their percussionist for example. You guys really have to give this guy a full cut of the door at the end of the night? Do your wallets a favor and drop him. Not necessary. He may be a brilliant musician. He may be the son of William fucking Winant and the world’s second greatest percussionist for all I know. But he still seems powerfully disposeable. I half expected them to ask the sound guy mid-song for more shaker in the mointors. In fact, the more I listen to this song over and over again. the more it becomes clear that everybody in this band is totally expendable except for the guy singing.
Speaking of the guy singing, you think he regrets anything in life? Because it sounds to me like he feels like he hasnt ever done anything right, and he wants us all to know about how sorry he is for it. This is exactly the kind of unimaginitive tripe that I expect to hear from bands that think they are cooler than they really are. I’ll bet this dude looked at his lyric sheet when he was done, saw he had successfully started practically every line with the words “I wish”, and really felt like that was clever. Ooh! look at how I’ve been able to sum up a failed relationship by rattling off a list of emotional contradictions. Perhaps it is my own emotional retardation that forces me to look at things in such a negative context, but I can’t really do too much about that. Any song written by a man that sounds this much like something that would come out of an Alanis Morrisette or a Taylor Swift, is not something I can take seriously. Not to say that emotional sincerity is something that I can’t handle or automatically reject, but I’m having a hard time coming to grips with the fact that anyone could listen to this guy boo-hoo about some girlfriend (or boyfriend, or maybe a family member? It’s just much easier to assume the lyrics are written about a woman, because to cry this hard about anything else would be even more emasculating than this song already is) and take it seriously, and be like all “yeah! this is my fuckin jam!” So to The Heavy Guilt, I say I hope this gig, and this song are netting you a windfall of pussy. The warm caress of an intemperate groupie in the middle of the night can really dull the sting of the realization that your music is pretty fuckin thin.
You know, now that I think about it, I have done a complete 180 on the band members. It is the singer who should be kissing all of the other guys asses. Without them “distracting” the audience, as I have put it. The dude that is whining would not be playing even at Winston’s but would be relegated to busking for coins at a fucking public transit center somewhere. Congratulations boys, on being able to latch on to someone that you can elevate to the point that you probably have a genuine shot at fame and fortune! This kind of shit really sells records! May you, the supporting cast of “The Heavy Guilt” recieve a windfall of pussy and money, and offers of artistic merit that is at least twice that of which your frontman receives. As you gentlemen are the Karl Rove to his George W Bush. The smoke, thunder and holographic projection to his “man behind the curtain”. The Edgar Bergen to his Mortimer Snerd. May all aspiring musicians enjoy the fortune that you fellows have!
DISCLAIMER! – “Mixed Messages” is the single, solitary song by “The Heavy Guilt” that I have heard. In my reference to the band, I speak as if this song was the entirety of their output. It is entirely possible that this song is the exception to the rule, and their other material may blow me away. Therefore, I reserve the right to at any point in the future reverse, alter, or modify my opinion of this or any other band.